Staffordshire Figures 1780-1840
  • Home
  • Books
  • Blog
  • Figures etc.
    • Some Fabulous Figures
    • Restoring Antique Staffordshire Pottery
    • Reproductions of Antique Staffordshire Pottery Figures
    • Believe It?
    • Dealers in Antique Staffordshire Pottery
    • Books on Staffordshire Pottery
    • Interesting Web Sites
  • Videos

A Peeler or a Sailor?

2/22/2023

0 Comments

 
I was pleasantly surprised---correction, I was thrilled---when the figure below crossed my path recently. This little man, made in the 1830s, has great presence and stands at a commanding 8.3 inches.  But who might he be?
antique Staffordshire pottery figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire figure, peeler, midshipman, Myrna Schkolne
antique Staffordshire pottery figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire figure, peeler, midshipman, Myrna Schkolne
The figure has excellent provenance, and an old label beneath attests to it previously having been in the stock of that esteemed dealer in English pottery, the late Jonathan Horne. Jonathan's label describes the figure as "a peeler or sailor," but which is he? Wiser heads than mine suggested the figure might be a midshipman, an entry-level officer in the British navy, so let's see if we can settle the question here.

What is a peeler? Today, British police are commonly called "Bobbies’," but originally they were dubbed "Peelers," both names being for Sir Robert Peel (1788 – 1850) who established London's police force in 1829. His officers wore blue tail coats and black top hats, a uniform that was deliberately chosen to ensure they blended in with ordinary folk. Each man carried a wooden rattle to raise the alarm and a wooden truncheon......but this figure carries a sword. Does this rule out his being a policeman? 


​Seems that wooden truncheons and rattles were not prerequisites for peacekeeping then. Some of the men who kept Britain's streets safe in that era carried steel. The sword-carrrying gentleman alongside is a Leeds policeman of between 1836 and 1860. Notice his tall black hat is like the hat the figure wears.
Picture
But I can't conclude the figure is a Peeler because those intrepid gentlemen apparently always sported coats with long tails, and our figure has a short jacket nipped at the waist. Given his gentlemanly appearance, might he then be a midshipman? 

Midshipmen in the British navy of that day were largely sons of professional men, as well as members of the peerage and landed gentry. Even Prince William, later King William IV, served as a midshipman in his youth. I have spent hours down the rabbit hole of naval uniforms, and I will spare you the details. Suffice it to say that the figure's hat is consistent with him being a midshipman.  ​

The prints below shows a midshipman of 1828 (left) and 1830 (right), and, like the figure, he has a tall hat and a sword. But, unlike the figure, he wears a coat with long tails. Images courtesy of the National Maritime Museum, Greenwich.
Picture
Picture
Notice the white patches on the coat collars. Midshipmen then always had white patches on their coat collars, and our figure lacks those. Also, midshipmen always had coats with tails, as befitted their gentlemanly status, and our figure has a short jacket of the sort you might expect to see on a common sailor. Might the figure instead be a sailor?
Common sailor wore a wide range of headgear, so its not improbably for a sailor to have worn a tall black hat rather like the one worn by a midshipman. Like the figure, the sailor illustrated below has a neckerchief, a tall black hat, and a short jacket. He has no sword, but I note that the figure's sword is short, as was the standard for common sailors then. I have to conclude that the figure is indeed a sailor.
Picture
Common Sailor, 1820s by Maxim Gauci 1828. Images courtesy of the National Maritime Museum, Greenwich.
Sailors were plentiful in their day, but this figure is very rare. I know of only one other example, and his trousers were painted with stripes. I was reluctant to base my decision on what may well have been artistic license, but, with hindsight I admit the answer was staring me in the face.
​

​I can't attribute this sailor to any specific potter, but I have noticed a small number of figures on similar bases, and I strongly suspect they too are of the 1830s period and from the same pot bank. 
Final image (C) The Victoria and Albert Museum, London.
0 Comments

Hunting for Pairs

12/11/2022

0 Comments

 
Small pearlware figures in fine condition remain the most elusive of Staffordshire figures. For generations, these little gems have been tossed aside--or tossed out--as fashions and tastes changed, but today collectors are wising up to their worth.

The best things are said to come in small parcels, and the same can often be said of early figures. The problem is that good, small figures are extraordinarily difficult to procure. And true pairs of small figures are nigh impossible. That's why my heart skipped a beat when this true pair of musicians popped onto the site of RTS Antiques. A pretty picture, are they not?
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware figures, showman, musician, tambourine, bugle,, Myrna Schkolne,
Courtesy RTS Antiques
The decoration confirms that they are the truest of pairs and have lived together always.  I have recorded a single example of each form, but I know of no other true pair.

​The male figure is known to me from the little fellow below in our collection. He is made from the same molds as RTS's male figure, but with a bocage added. I bought him over thirty years ago, and I have yet to see another.
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware figures, showman, musician, tambourine, bugle,, Myrna Schkolne,
I value my perky musician so highly that I placed him on the spine of the dust jacket of my first book, People, Passions, Pastimes, and Pleasure: Staffordshire Figures 1810-1835. I have not yet seen another, and I have assumed that his mate looks like the lady in the pair above. Imagine my surprise when this rather blitzed figure appeared on eBay recently. The bocage has been lost.
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware figures, showman, musician, tambourine, bugle,, Myrna Schkolne,
I suspect that this lady is my musician's companion, but I must await a better example. But, as it has taken me thirty years to come up with this one, I am running out of time!  

By the way, all the musicians above have impressed numbers in their bases, suggesting Enoch Wood probably made them. The bocage on my male figure is also consistent with that attribution.

If pairs are so difficult to find, imagine the odds of assembling a hunting garniture, such as this one. All the figures are marked WALTON.
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware figures, Walton, John Walton, sportsman, garniture, hunting, dog, hare,  Myrna Schkolne,
If you can find the pair of sportsmen, you are well on your way to assembling the garniture because four animal subjects have been recorded, any one  of which will transform the pair into a garniture. If you are so inclined, RTS Antiques has this rare twosome available.
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware figures, Walton, John Walton, sportsman, garniture, hunting, dog, hare,  Myrna Schkolne,
Courtesy RTS Antiques
This has been the most barren of years for early figures, but I am constantly digging for the unusual. Amongst the unrecorded figures I have unearthed is this example of a lady, and, to my mind, she is a candidate for the Ugliest Woman of the Year award.
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware figures,  Myrna Schkolne,
Courtesy Dovetail Auctions.
I was intrigued by the lady holding a book, below. She went through auction described as Faith, and she is in the stock of a dealer, again described as Faith. The problem is that Faith typically holds a cross, whereas this lady clutches a large tome. Some might think it to be a Bible, but I suspect otherwise.
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware figures, Metis, Calliope, Caliope, Faith,  Myrna Schkolne,
Courtesy Cromwell's Antiques.
The figure is most probably Metis, the goddess of deep thought and wisdom, or perhaps Calliope, the muse of epic poetry. You can see more on this subject here.

The figure on the left below caught my eye on eBay. She portrays Peace. This is a common enough figure, but for one thing: the head is different. The head on the figure is usually formed like that on the right.
​
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware figures, Peace,  Myrna Schkolne,
Courtesy eBay.
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware figures, Peace,  Myrna Schkolne,
If the head is indeed a "transplant" from another figure, it has been very well done and it sits quite naturally, Although one or two suspicious little bumps around the neck warrant further investigation, we may have yet another version of this otherwise common figure form.

Finding the unusual makes collecting fun, so enjoy your hunting. And remember to grab fine pairs when you can!
0 Comments

Sherratt Figures: A Photo Index

10/27/2022

0 Comments

 
Those of you who collect early figures purely because they are eye-candy will be able to gorge on my latest effort, which includes very sparse text and tons of glorious color images. 

In 1991, Malcolm and Judith Hodkinson published Sherratt? A Natural Family of Staffordshire Figures. Their groundbreaking work included an alphabetical listing of Sherratt models illustrated with small black and white images. In the ensuing thirty-plus years, further models have, of course, come to light, and for that reason I have assembled an updated photo record. It is available as a free download on the BOOKS menu at the top of this page or click
 here.

Picture
0 Comments

Ralph Wood: My Notebook.

10/4/2022

0 Comments

 
Picture
I have compiled much of what I have learned about Ralph Wood figures into a notebook, which is available for free download on the BOOKS tab at the top of this page. Ralph Wood was the Father of the British figure making industry, and I find his figures endlessly fascinating. I know many will consider this a nerdy topic, so those wanting only a list of the numbered models should start on page 19.
0 Comments

Fall Finds

9/10/2022

0 Comments

 
When there is nothing worth saying, it is always best to keep silent. For that reason, this blog has been quiet these many months. I have already covered so much material here in the past fifteen years, and next to nothing else of note has appeared on the market of late. Admittedly, gorgeous pieces of great rarity do exist, but they seem to be glued to collectors' shelves. The most exciting group to pop up this year is the stunning one below.
rare pearlware figure, antique staffordshire pottery, staffordshire figure, early staffordshire, Walton, nanny, dog, boy, bocage, Myrna SchkolnePicture
Courtesy Bonhams.
The eye-catching bocage on this group is very uncommon, and, best of all, in this instance it is in outstanding condition. Figures with this bocage are few and far between, and when I was working on Staffordshire Figures 1780-1840, I had no basis for attributing them. My gut suggested Walton, but waving the flag for Walton or any other potter is treacherous without hard facts to back up the attribution. As luck would have it, in the last three or so years, two figures with this very bocage have come to light, both MARKED Walton, so the attribution finally stands on terra firma. Shown below, they are a lion and a Widow, both sporting this bocage form and John Walton's mark.
rare pearlware figure, antique staffordshire pottery, staffordshire figure, early staffordshire, Walton, lion, bocage, Myrna SchkolnePicture
rare pearlware figure, antique staffordshire pottery, staffordshire figure, early staffordshire, Walton, Widow, bocage, Myrna SchkolnePicture
I delve through a lot of junk on the internet each week, always in the hope of finding something new or different. In June, I was tickled to see this cow at auction. At first glance, she is a pretty yet rather ordinary beast, but her name, LADY, impressed on the front makes her special. 
rare pearlware figure, antique staffordshire pottery, staffordshire fearly staffordshire, gardener, Myrna Schkolne
A friend and I exchanged emails, jokingly suggesting names for the companion bull. We only had to wait till September to learn that the companion was a cow rather than a bull, and her name is ANN.
rare pearlware figure, antique staffordshire pottery, staffordshire figure, early staffordshire, cow, Myrna Schkolne
These animals came to auction at the same auction house, three months apart. I assume they came from the same source, and, if that is the case, to my mind splitting them into different lots at the same auction would have been very sad, but placing them in different auctions months apart was stupid and tragic. I am pointing no finger at the auction house because the fault may well lie with the consignor. I do hope that the same bidder acquired both LADY and ANN so they can spend their days side by side once more. 

I am always on the lookout for figures that help me or others complete pairs. The little gardener lady on the left caught my eye recently. She is a humble purchase on Etsy, and, if you own the man alongside, sold by Andrew Dando some years ago, you may want to buy her to complete the pair.
rare pearlware figure, antique staffordshire pottery, staffordshire figure, early staffordshire, gardener, Myrna Schkolne
Courtesy PFTPAntiqueSales on Etsy
rare pearlware figure, antique staffordshire pottery, staffordshire figure, early staffordshire, gardener, Myrna Schkolne
Courtesy Andrew Dando.
Lastly, I am a little puzzled as to the identity of these two figures. They differ only in the objects that they hold
rare pearlware figure, antique staffordshire pottery, staffordshire figure, early staffordshire, St. Margaret, Myrna Schkolne
The figure on the right, above, is thought to be St. Margaret, the pearls she wears being critical to that identification. Below are two other figures of St Margaret.
rare pearlware figure, antique staffordshire pottery, staffordshire figure, early staffordshire, St. Margaret, Myrna Schkolne
As the figure in the pink dress on the left also wears pearls, might she too be St. Margaret? I doubt it, but I am out of my depth, so if you know the answer, please shout. 
0 Comments

Wood?

5/28/2022

1 Comment

 
Sadly, small figures  routinely fly under the radar because collectors all seem to prefer trophy additions to their collections. This little lady might have slipped into oblivion had Andrew Dando not rescued her and brought her to my attention.
antique Staffordshire pottery figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire figure , Ralph Wood, Myrna Schkolne,
antique Staffordshire pottery figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire figure , Ralph Wood, Myrna Schkolne,
The blue-tinged glaze puddling on the base is fabulous, is it not? But the enameled decoration is particulary interesting and strongly reminiscent of that found on Ralph Wood figures. 

​
Experienced collectors ALWAYS immediately turn over a figure to scrutinize the underneath, which can reveal a wealth of nuanced information. In this case it delivered an added surprise: an unrecorded mark!
antique Staffordshire pottery figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire figure , Ralph Wood, Myrna Schkolne,
"Wood." The first name that comes to mind is that of Ralph Wood, the father of English figure pottery, who was active as a potter from 1782 to 1795. Might he have made this figure?

The combination of rainbow colors on the mound beneath the figure is very, very typical of Ralph Wood, and I have until now only seen mounds colored thus on figures with a Ralph Wood attribution

Also, the lady's face is painted in a typical, delicate Ralph Wood style. If you organize figures into groups by their pot bank of origin, there is a striking family resemblance within each group. A Neale face is very different from a Lakin & Poole face or a Ralph Wood face. The difference sometimes is in the modeling, but it is very often in the decoration. Each manufacturer had a "house style" that painters followed.

By now we all know that when Ralph Wood's painters placed lines around bases, the lines banded three sides of each base, with the back typically left plain. On this figure, the line is on one side only. Make of it this what you will. Did the painter intend placing more lines? Did he get confused? Was it a Monday--a day that invariably started with a hangover? Who knows? 

Then there is the manner in which the base was formed. Looked at from beneath, it has rounded internal corners. Nearly all Ralph Wood bases are formed in this manner, whereas the bases of figures made by Wood's contemporaries are usually formed differently.

And finally there is the mark itself. Ralph Wood consistently impressed the mark into the clay bodies of his figures, but this mark is painted. Wood's painters used tiny red letters to title very many figures, and the "Wood" mark is in tiny red letters. However, the letters are different to the "house style" used for Ralph Wood titles. Note the "W" consists of two Vs, and the "d" has a long curly handle. 

What other Wood might have made this figure? The names of Enoch Wood and John Wood pop to mind. For about twenty years, a whacky theory credited them with making all the Ralph Wood figures---yes, even those with Ralph Wood's name impressed into their clay bodies! Fortunately, that theory has been resoundingly debunked, but museums that lack knowledgable curatorial staff (and updated libraries, it seems) persist in stupidly crediting Ralph Wood figures to Ralph's cousin Enoch Wood or to his brother John Wood. But there is no evidence that John Wood made any figures at all. Enoch Wood made figures, but they are in a very different style to the little lady in question.

Bottom line is that my heart tells me that this is a Ralph Wood figure. I would bet money on it if I could--and I am not a betting person. But my head must rule, and I admit that there is inadequate evidence for a water-tight attribution. I can't tell you how much time I have spent looking at her and pondering. She has added enormously to my collecting pleasure. 

By the way, the molds for this figure, like other Ralph Wood molds, circulated in the Potteries for decades, and other potters made their own versions. Not one has a single Ralph Wood attribute.
antique Staffordshire pottery figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire figure , gardener, Myrna Schkolne,
antique Staffordshire pottery figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire figure , gardener, Myrna Schkolne,
antique Staffordshire pottery figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire figure , gardener, Myrna Schkolne,
antique Staffordshire pottery figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire figure , gardener, Myrna Schkolne,
Image at bottom right is courtesy of Andrew Dando.
1 Comment

A Powerful Punch

3/1/2022

2 Comments

 
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware plaque, plaque, Cromwell, King Charles, Galatea, Eris, Judgment of Paris, mythology, Myrna Schkolne
Oliver Cromwell (1599-1658) was the Protestant general who overthrew England’s ruler, King Charles I (1600-1649). A deeply religious man, Cromwell believed God led him to victory, so I guess he also thought God wanted him to sign King Charles’s death warrant, and the unfortunate monarch succumbed to the executioner’s sword. The story of the rise and fall of England’s short-lived Commonwealth is well known, so I shan’t belabor it here, but Cromwell and King Charles resurfaced in English figure pottery well over a century later, standing side by side on this huge plaque. Breathtakingly beautiful, it measures almost fourteen inches across.
 
A plaque in a blog devoted to figures may surprise you, but plaques with relief figural forms are, to my mind, figures too. I find them particularly gorgeous because light dances across their glazed flat surfaces in a way that just is not possible on conventional figures. And when the plaque is as large as this one, the result is mesmerizing.
 
Each plaque, like each figure, tells a story, but this plaque is a brain teaser that raises numerous questions. Why give Cromwell a passing thought some 160 years after his death? When King Charles II reclaimed the throne his father had relinquished, he disinterred Cromwell’s body, publicly hanged and then beheaded it, and placed the head on a spike for all to see. But, as modern day protestors have yet to learn, you cannot erase history, and in time Staffordshire potters turned their attention to Cromwell and his ill-fated victim.   

​What probably got the potters’ creative juices flowing was this engraving of Cromwell after a drawing by Samuel Wale, the eighteenth century historical painter and book illustrator. It appeared in George Frederick Raymond’s “A New, Universal and Impartial History of England” that was first published in serial form in the late 1780s.

Picture
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware plaque, plaque, Cromwell, King Charles, Galatea, Eris, Judgment of Paris, mythology, Myrna Schkolne
Wale was probably guided by an earlier painting of Cromwell, but, to my eye, much was lost in the translation. Anyway, as it was all that potters had to go on, they made do.
​Also courtesy of Samuel Wale  is this engraving of King Charles, orb and scepter in his regal hands and his head still upon his shoulders. It clearly is the design source for figure of Charles on the plaque.
Picture
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware plaque, plaque, Cromwell, King Charles, Galatea, Eris, Judgment of Paris, mythology, Myrna Schkolne
​What of the classical maidens to either  side of the king and his persecutor? Collectors today overlook classical figures, but, to my mind, they are endlessly fascinating, and the damsels on this plaque are no exception.

​The figure on the left is the sea nymph Galatea. The raised scarf is the give-away because Galatea is routinely portrayed in art with a raised scarf. Her story goes like this: Galatea, fleeing from her jealous lover, travelled on the ocean in a shell drawn by sea creatures, and her scarf caught the wind and acted as a sail. On the plaque, Galatea, balancing on her shell, taps Charles on the shoulder, signaling the need to flee. 
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware plaque, plaque, Cromwell, King Charles, Galatea, Eris, Judgment of Paris, mythology, Myrna Schkolne
On the underglaze plaque below, you see a fuller version of Galatea's tale. ​
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware plaque, plaque, Cromwell, King Charles, Galatea, Eris, Judgment of Paris, mythology, Myrna Schkolne
The figure on the right too has a story to tell. She is the goddess Eris. In Greek her name means strife, and she was the goddess of discord. Miffed at not being invited to a wedding, Eris gate-crashed the event and tossed down an apple with the words “to the fairest one” inscribed on it. The apple—appropriately known as the Apple of Discord—resulted in a beauty contest, and Paris of Troy was left with the task of deciding whether to award the apple to Athena, Hera, or Aphrodite. Paris could not win this one! Never underestimate the fury of a woman scorned. The resulting conflict led to the  legendary ten-year Trojan War. On the plaque, Eris stands with the Apple of Discord in her hand. She symbolizes the discord between Cromwell and King Charles.
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware plaque, plaque, Cromwell, King Charles, Galatea, Eris, Judgment of Paris, mythology, Myrna Schkolne
​The same motif also occurs on the plaque below, where Paris awards the apple to Aphrodite. It was probably inspired by a painting, perhaps Botticelli’s beautiful portrayal of the Judgment of Paris. The potter skillfully reworked the motif used for Aphrodite so that the female figure stood alone, apple in hand…and presto! she became Eris. Or perhaps it was the other way around, and the potter transformed Eris into Aphrodite.
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware plaque, plaque, Cromwell, King Charles, Galatea, Eris, Judgment of Paris, mythology, Myrna Schkolne
Courtesy Andrew Dando
Picture
Sandro Botticelli's Judgment of Paris
What about the animals in the foreground of the plaque? I am somewhat stumped. Perhaps the birds are doves, signifying a hope for peace. The huge serpent surely symbolizes evil, no doubt a reference to Cromwell’s dastardly deeds. As for the dog, apparently sleeping and oblivious to all around him, I have no idea---but I shall be thinking about it. I notice that the same dog is on the plaque of the Judgment of Paris, so perhaps the potter included it simply because he had a mould at hand.
 
So the King, the man who usurped England’s throne, discord, and flight, all in one eyeful. This plaque packs a powerful punch.

PS:
​For completeness, I add that small pair of underglaze decorated plaques in the Wolverhampton Museum & Art Gallery is illustrated in Lewis, Pratt Ware, pp. 114-115. One has a relief of Cromwell, another of King Charles. The plaques are not accessible on the museum's web site. I surmise that these little treasures, like so many others, are buried and forgotten in museum storage.
​
Picture
Courtesy Brighton and Hove Museums.
Also, Samuel Wale's print of Cromwell was the design source for this rare figure of Cromwell in the Brighton and Hove Museums. It was made by Ralph Wood circa 1790, and I have recorded an example impressed "20".​
2 Comments

Obsession

1/1/2022

0 Comments

 
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware figures, Obsession, book, Myrna Schkolne,  Schkolne collection
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware figures, Obsession, book, Myrna Schkolne,  Schkolne collection
antique Staffordshire pottery, pearlware figures, Obsession, book, Myrna Schkolne,  Schkolne collection
I have updated my three volumes of my eBook, Obsession, to reflect changes in our collection and advances in my knowledge. The book is available for free download on my Books menu on this site. 
0 Comments

The Dating Game

1/1/2022

0 Comments

 
As 2021 fades with a whimper, I look back on the extraordinary figures that have crossed my path. The variety that emanated from Staffordshire kilns is seemingly endless.  I confine my collection to  enamel-painted figures. If not, I would have had to bid on this remarkable underglaze-decorated figure of Roger Giles.
antique Staffordshire figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire pottery,  Roger Giles, Myrna Schkolne
Courtesy Burstow & Hewett.
antique Staffordshire figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire pottery,  Roger Giles, Myrna Schkolne
Roger Giles was a Devonshire schoolteacher and jack-of-all-trades. His claim to fame rests is that he advertised for sale fresh eggs “new laid by him every day”. Staffordshire figure potters fashioned crudely comical figures of a squatting gentleman that are said to represent Giles laying those eggs. They were made well into the Victorian era, and nasty fake-similes persist today, but a pre-1840 Roger Giles can prove elusive. Add to that, some can be a tad too vulgar for my taste.

Below is my Roger Giles, made by the "Sherratt" pot bank. Like others of his ilk, he has holes in his hat, so perhaps he was intended as a pepper pot or hat pin holder. Like most, he is about 4.5 inches tall--significantly smaller than the gentleman at the top of this post. At a good 8 inches, that Roger Giles is by  far the biggest I have seen, and the top of his head is removable (is he a jar?). He oozes personality, and I am pleased he has found a home in a remarkably interesting and fine collection. 
antique Staffordshire figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire pottery,  Obadiah Sherratt, Roger Giles, Myrna Schkolne
antique Staffordshire figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire pottery,  Obadiah Sherratt, Roger Giles, Myrna Schkolne
Another unrecorded figure that quietly changed hands recently was this gem that went through auction in a lot with another. Described as a "figure playing a lyre," he is Apollo, but given the girly hairstyle (not to mention our "Woke" world),  the description was probably intentionally gender-neutral. What is interesting about Apollo is that he can be attributed to John Dale. The distinctive bocage flowers nail the attribution, and the decoration of the base is rather like that on other Dale figures.
antique Staffordshire figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire pottery,  John Dale, Apollo, Myrna Schkolne
Courtesy Skinner Inc.
 These same Dale features (and others) are apparent on the spill vase below. (See Staffordshire Figures 1780-1840, vol.1 for Dale attributes.)
antique Staffordshire figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire pottery,  John Dale, Myrna Schkolne
Courtesy the William Herbert and Nancy Hunt Collection.
John Dale was active as a potter from 1818, and Apollo looks like a circa 1820s figure. Dale made other classical figures in the same style (with various but typical Dale bocages and bases), as recorded in Staffordshire Figures 1780-1840, vol.4. From top left they Aesculapius, Bacchus, Venus, Juno, and Mercury. Today, all are particularly rare and are known from one or two examples at most. Click each image to enlarge.
Clearly there was a significant market for classical figures in the 1820s, yet collectors tend to relegate those figures to earlier decades. How wrong that would be, and a message from the grave hammers home that lesson. Let me explain.

​The enamels on this figure group of Peace below suggest it was made in the 1790s. On the base are a helmet and other implements of war as well as a broken chain, all of which symbolize the fight for freedom. The male figure holds a shield decorated with the fleur-de-lys of the French monarchy, and he is laying down his arms at the feet of the the female, who is Peace. She is offering him a Liberty bonnet. Clasped hands of fraternity are on the obelisk, so the group has been interpreted as suggesting or commemorating a peaceful resolution of the French Revolution. Given that, a date in the 1790s seems appropriate for this group.
antique Staffordshire figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire pottery,  Enoch Wood, Peace, Liberty, French Revolution, Myrna Schkolne
As the French revolution was finite, one would have expected this model to have outlived its usefulness by 1800. Would you even consider dating an example to the 1820s? No? Think again! Fast forward to 1974, and this unpainted group, from the same molds, was unearthed in Staffordshire. (The helmet probably went the way of the lady's arm!)
antique Staffordshire figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire pottery,  Enoch Wood, Peace, Liberty, French Revolution, Myrna Schkolne
The potter Enoch Wood was a great recorder of the events of his day. For that purpose, he buried caches of his pottery for future historians to find. When the foundation of St. Paul's Church, Burslem, was laid in 1828, Wood left a cache beneath it. Included was this group of Peace. A demolition contractor unearthed it in 1974, and  it came to auction last year. No saying for certain when it was made, but I strongly suspect it was made in the 1820s rather than the 1790s.

​Also in the cache was a shard corresponding to a figure of Medea, as seen below. Again, it seems reasonable to conclude that as the shard was made in the 1820s, the figure may have been made then too. While there is no hard line in the sand, classical figures on square bases with a line are assumed to predate 1815.
antique Staffordshire figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire pottery,  Enoch Wood, Medea, Myrna Schkolne
Courtesy Stoke Museums.
Enoch Wood's legacy does not end there. In 1938, a cache of his wares was unearthed beneath the Burslem Old Town Hall. From their subject matter, they date to the 1820s. Among them were shards of classical figures of Bacchus and Ariadne that, like Medea, we might have relegated to an earlier period based on their bases, their designs, and their subject matter. The shards are below. Alongside the shard of Ariadne is a figure corresponding to it.
antique Staffordshire figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire pottery,  Enoch Wood, Bacchus, Myrna Schkolne
antique Staffordshire figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire pottery,  Enoch Wood, Ariadne, Myrna Schkolne
antique Staffordshire figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire pottery,  Enoch Wood, Ariadne, Myrna Schkolne
Does that mean that all examples of Bacchus and Ariadne from these molds date to the 1820s? Not at all. Rather, it means that we have to broaden our time horizon. We must look beyond square bases to determine a date.

The mode of decoration and the colors of the enamels can be very helpful. The soft turquoise enamel on Ariadne was in great favor in the 1790s, but that is not enough to assign a date with confidence. Turquoise had no sell-by date, and it certainly may have been used for a lot longer.

I only know of three examples of the large group of Peace: the two shown above, and the one below. I apologize for the partial photo, but the full image is lost somewhere in my archive. 
antique Staffordshire figure, pearlware figure, Staffordshire pottery,  Enoch Wood, Peace, Liberty, French Revolution, Myrna Schkolne
Courtesy Xupes.
Because it is uncolored, the details of the modeling are particularly crisp. But, as there are no enamels to guide dating (however unreliable or reliable that might be) we are up the creek without a paddle. This group could have been made at any time from the 1790s into the late 1820s. 

​We rely on multiple features to support an attribution, but we tend to be rather gung-ho about dating. I intend being very much more circumspect henceforth. It bothers me that collectors and dealers alike consistently pull the dates of their pieces forward in the belief that an earlier dates equates with greater worth. That is simply ridiculous. Let us all practice greater caution in the new year.

PS. Andrew Dando has a lovely little "Sherratt" Roger Giles in stock currently. Like mine, shown above but in a red coat. 
0 Comments

What's in a Name?

11/1/2021

1 Comment

 
antique Staffordshire figure, Staffordshire bust, Staffordshire pottery, pearlware bust, President Andrew Jackson,, Myrna Schkolne
Courtesy Neal Auctions.
This rather clunky bust hardly seems remarkable enough to head even this month’s humble blog post, but it proves to be noteworthy in several ways, not all of which are favorable. I think most of you would agree that a thing of beauty it is not, but what makes it unusual is that it is titled GENL JACKSON PRESIDENT, US. No other Staffordshire bust of Andrew Jackson (who served as America’s seventh president from 1829-1837) had been recorded when this example came up for auction late this summer.

This bust had a hard life. Apparent to the naked eye were the deteriorated enamels—grungy at best and “chewed” or flaked off at worst, but the damage was more than skin deep. The condition report revealed that there were “restorations to head…to nose, chin, large crack around head.”
 
I searched for a design source for the bust but quickly learned that Jackson looked rather different. In particular, he is typically shown with puffy rather than slicked down hair, usually  brushed back rather than forward. Add to this, the features did not seem to resemble Jackson’s either.
Picture
Picture
​Jackson was in his sixties when he served as President (and the two images above date from that period). As the gentleman in the bust seems significantly younger, I thought a print of a more youthful Jackson served as the design source, but again, I failed to see any resemblance to this print of circa 1812.
Picture
Last of all, I could find scant association between the oak leaves liberally adorning the tunic of the gentleman in the bust and Jackson. Samuel Lovett Waldo’s portrait of Jackson, done in 1819, was the closest I could come, and here you can just see an oak leaf on the collar. 
Picture
On the other hand, a tunic decorated with oak leaves screams Napoleon Bonaparte. From 1795, Napoleon's rank entitled him to wear a coat with red collar and cuffs embroidered with gold oak-leaves. Could the bust perhaps have originally been modeled to portray Napoleon? It certainly resembles Staffordshire busts of Napoleon, like the one shown below (and titled on the reverse).  But who am I to argue with a name? The bust is clearly titled Jackson, so Jackson it must be.
antique Staffordshire figure, Staffordshire bust, Staffordshire pottery, pearlware bust, Napoleon Bonaparte,, Myrna Schkolne
Courtesy John Howard
​I know there is a distinct market for Americana, but I was still surprised to see the battered bust fetch just over $4,000 with charges at Neal Auction Company. But for the title, it would not have fetched $400. I will admit that the price bothered me. Such silly money for a vastly inferior object just because of the name.  But this was only the beginning of the story.
 
Fast forward a month or two, and an identical bust came up for sale at Bonhams, London. I say identical, but there were several differences. The Bonhams bust was in much better condition, but it lacked a title. Bonhams’ experts—no doubt aware of the Jackson bust—had nonetheless identified their bust as Napoleon modeled as First Consul.  

​
antique Staffordshire figure, Staffordshire bust, Staffordshire pottery, pearlware bust, Napoleon Bonaparte,, Myrna Schkolne
Courtesy Bonhams
In the same sale was this French porcelain bust of Bonaparte as First Consul. Notice the resemblance to the Staffordshire bust.
Picture
Courtesy Bonahms
In my humble opinion, Bonhams was correct. I believe that the bust was intended to be Napoleon, but somewhere along the line Jackson’s name was impressed into one (as best we know) example to make it suitable for the American market.
 
There is no telling what crazy money will pursue, and someone apparently thought that Bonhams’ untitled bust too portrayed Jackson. And what did the buyer pay? Are you sitting down: GBP 7,650 ($10,511).  This price bothers me less than the $4,000 paid for the beaten-up, titled bust. At least Bonham's bust is a fine example….but it is unremarkable and only made the price it did because somebody thought it was Jackson!
 
So what is the value of a name? I have a beautiful bust of George Washington. It is titled AND it closely resembles him. Any one care to make me an insanely high offer? And I have a number of untitled busts. Buy one, and you can call it whatever tickles your fancy.

My thanks to that great collector, my friend Bob Carde, for making me think through this issue and for his invaluable input.
1 Comment
<<Previous
    Myrna Schkolne, antique Staffordshire pottery, expert
    antique Staffordshire pottery, Staffordshire figure, bocage, antique Staffordshire, Myrna Schkolne
    Staffordshire figure, Myrna Schkolne, pearlware figure, creamware, bocage figure, antique Staffordshire pottery
    Staffordshire figure, Myrna Schkolne, pearlware figure, creamware, bocage figure, antique Staffordshire pottery
    Staffordshire figure, Myrna Schkolne, pearlware figure, creamware, bocage figure, antique Staffordshire pottery
    Staffordshire figure, Myrna Schkolne, pearlware figure, creamware, bocage figure, antique Staffordshire pottery
    Staffordshire figure, Myrna Schkolne, pearlware figure, creamware, bocage figure, antique Staffordshire pottery
    antique Staffordshire pottery, Staffordshire figure, bocage, antique Staffordshire, Myrna Schkolnecture
    antique Staffordshire pottery, Staffordshire figure, bocage, antique Staffordshire, Myrna Schkolne
    antique Staffordshire pottery, Staffordshire figure, bocage, antique Staffordshire, Myrna Schkolne
    antique Staffordshire pottery, Staffordshire figure, Ralph Wood, antique Staffordshire, Myrna Schkolne
    antique Staffordshire pottery, Staffordshire figure, Obadiah Sherratt, antique Staffordshire, Myrna Schkolne

    Archives

    December 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    May 2022
    March 2022
    January 2022
    November 2021
    August 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    February 2021
    December 2020
    October 2020
    August 2020
    June 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010
    April 2010
    March 2010
    February 2010
    January 2010
    December 2009
    November 2009
    October 2009
    September 2009
    August 2009
    July 2009
    June 2009
    May 2009
    April 2009
    March 2009
    February 2009
    January 2009
    December 2008
    November 2008
    October 2008
    September 2008
    August 2008

    All material on this website is protected by copyright law. You may link to this site from your site, but please contact Myrna if you wish to reproduce any of this material elsewhere.


Visit earlystaffordshirefigures.com